Date this file last edited - 24 October 2003
ASTROM_0001 validation comments, (by S.L. Adams)
> 1. AAREADME.TXT
>
> A. Recommend "spelling out" initial abbreviations the first
> time they are used, (for the benefit of the uninitiated),
> for example, on line 20:
>
> Change
>
> The data were obtained using the HST/WFPC2 over the
> period 1994-2002.
>
> To
>
> The data were obtained using the Hubble Space Telescope/
> Wide Field Planetary Camera, mod 2, (HST/WFPC2) over the
> period 1994-2002.
Done.
> B. Lines 203 and 204. Be sure to replace ???? with the
> appropriate text when known and before final delivery.
> (You know this already, just noted here for documentation
> purposes and record keeping.)
Done.
> C. line 8 and line 100, capitalize "ascii"
> (i.e. ASCII instead of ascii).
Done.
> D. Consider changing (minor cleanup) . . .
>
> |
> |-DATA Directories containing astrometric data in
> | | ascii table files.
> | |
> | |-EASYDATA/
> | | |-x.TAB Astrometric data for one satellite, where
> | | | the x is replaced by the name of the satellite.
> | | |
> | | |-x.LBL Detached PDS labels for the above.
> | |
> | |-SORCDATA/
> | | |-x_TABLE_REVnn.TXT Original text file supplied by R. French.
> | | | x is replaced by the satellite name and
> | | | nn is replaced by either 2 or 2A.
> | | |
> | | |-x_TABLE_REVnn.LBL Detached PDS labels for the above.
> | |
>
> |
> |-CATALOG/ A directory containing PDS catalog
> | | information, providing high-level descriptions
> | | of the data, instruments, etc.
> | |
> | |-CATINFO.TXT Description of the files in this directory.
>
>
> To . . .
>
> |
> |-DATA Directories containing astrometric data in
> | | ascii table files.
> | |
> | |-EASYDATA/
> | | |-x.TAB Astrometric data for one satellite, where
> | | | the x is replaced by the name of the satellite.
> | | |
> | | |-x.LBL Detached PDS labels for the above.
> | |
> | |-SORCDATA/
> | |-x_TABLE_REVnn.TXT Original text file supplied by R. French.
> | | x is replaced by the satellite name and
> | | nn is replaced by either 2 or 2A.
> | |
> | |-x_TABLE_REVnn.LBL Detached PDS labels for the above.
> |
> |
> |-CATALOG/ A directory containing PDS catalog
> | | information, providing high-level descriptions
> | | of the data, instruments, etc.
> | |
> | |-CATINFO.TXT Description of the files in this directory.
>
>
> Likewise, on lines 136 and 146, delete second occurance of
> vertical bar "|". (Very minor, just looks a little cleaner).
>
> 2. VOLDESC.CAT
>
> A. line 17, capitalize "ascii", (as 1.C. above)
>
> B. line 23, FACILITY_NAME = "SPACE SCIENCE DIVISION"
>
> Didn't we make a notation about this before? The existing
> standard value is "SPACE SCIENCE LABORATORY". If DIVISION
> is really what it should be, let's get into the dd so we
> don't keep getting this error.
Corrected.
> 3. ERRATA.TXT
>
> A. Consider changing, (but not necessary)
>
> There are no know errors in this data set.
>
> To
>
> There are no know errors in this data set or
> deviations from current PDS standards on this volume.
Reported a known deviation.
> 4. \CATALOG\CATINFO.TXT
>
> A. line 36 and 37 - delete these two lines. They describe the
> MISSION.CAT is currently missing and will be added later.
> The MISSION.CAT is included on this volume, so these two
> lines no longer valid.
Done.
> 5. \CATALOG\DATASET.CAT
>
> A. lines 93, 94, and 95 - see (1.B.) above.
Done.
> B. line 10,
>
> Change: ARCHIVE_STATUS = "PRE PEER REVIEW"
>
> To: ARCHIVE_STATUS = "PRE_PEER_REVIEW"
>
> Or: ARCHIVE_STATUS = PRE_PEER_REVIEW
Changed Status to "ARCHIVED"
> C. Please include a LABEL_REVISION_NOTE keyword/value.
Done.
> 6. \CATALOG\INST.CAT
>
> A. BURROWSETAL1991 needs to be added to the REF.CAT on this
> volume.
Done.
> B. This version of INST.CAT that Mark edited looks to be an
> update of the existing INST.CAT for the HST\WFPC2 that
> already exists in the data dictionary. Other than spell
> check and basic grammer, I have not read for scientific
> content or understanding and will trust that the info you
> have included is valid.
Made additional minor
changes. This version should be ingested.
> C. The existing INST.CAT for HST/WFPC2 has the following
> values:
>
> INSTRUMENT_NAME = "HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE"
> INSTRUMENT_TYPE = "WIDE FIELD PLANETARY CAMERA 2"
>
> This file has:
>
> INSTRUMENT_NAME = "WIDE FIELD PLANETARY CAMERA 2"
> INSTRUMENT_TYPE = "CAMERA"
>
> Which is correct? The old values, or these new values?
> What values should we use that are the most accurate?
>
> The dd has the following values:
> INSTRUMENT_NAME = "CAMERA 1"
> INSTRUMENT_NAME = "CAMERA 2"
> INSTRUMENT_TYPE = "WIDE FIELD PLANETARY CAMERA 2"
> INSTRUMENT_TYPE = "CCD CAMERA")
>
> My preference (that makes the most sense to me) would
> be (for this entire volume):
>
> INSTRUMENT_NAME = "WIDE FIELD PLANETARY CAMERA 2"
> INSTRUMENT_ID = WFPC2
> INSTRUMENT_TYPE = "CCD CAMERA"
> INSTRUMENT_HOST_NAME = "HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE"
> INSTRUMENT_HOST_ID = HST
We agree and have
incorporated these values.
> 7. \CATALOG\INSTHOST.CAT
>
> A. REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BURROWSETAL1991"
> See (6.A.) above.
Done.
> B. Updated INSTHOST.CAT that already exists in data
> dictionary? Same comments as (6.B.) above.
Made additional minor
changes. This version should be ingested.
> 8. \CATALOG\MISSION.CAT
>
> A. REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BURROWSETAL1991"
> See comment (6.A.) above.
Done.
> B. You have a MISSION_TARGET object for CHARON. There does
> not exist a TARGET.CAT for CHARON in the data dictionary.
> One will be needed before volume is ingested into the PDS.
Rewrote the MISSION.CAT to
identify the observing campaign rather than the HST as the mission.
> 9. \CATALOG\PERSON.CAT
>
> A. line 12
>
> Change ALTERNATE_TELEPHONE_NUMBER = 'N/A'
> To ALTERNATE_TELEPHONE_NUMBER = "N/A"
>
Done.
> B. line 14, line 40, line 118
>
> Change INSTITUTION_NAME = "NASA AMES RESEARCH CENTER"
> To INSTITUTION_NAME = "NASA/AMES RESEARCH CENTER"
Done.
> C. line 42, this file - PDS_AFFILIATION = "RINGS NODE-MANAGER"
> data dictionary - PDS_AFFILIATION = "NODE-RINGS MANAGER"
>
> Which is correct, or prefered (or a
> third choice, "RINGS - NODE MANAGER")?
Used "RINGS NODE
MANAGER"
> D. line 43, this file - REGISTRATION_DATE = "N/A"
> data dictionary - REGISTRATION_DATE = "1990-02-09"
>
> insert dd value instead of "N/A"
Done.
> E. line 68, this file - PDS_AFFILIATION = "RINGS NODE-ADV GROUP"
> data dictionary - PDS_AFFILIATION = "NODE ADV GROUP"
>
> please verify correct keyword value.
Use "RINGS NODE ADVISORY
COUNCIL"
> F. line 69, this file - REGISTRATION_DATE = "UNK"
> data dictionary has - REGISTRATION_DATE = "1994-02-21"
>
> Insert dd value for "UNK".
Done.
> G. lines 71, 72, & 73
> this file - ADDRESS_TEXT = "ASTRONOMY DEPARTMENT
> WELLESLEY COLLEGE
> WELLESLEY, MA 02181"
>
> data dictionary - ADDRESS_TEXT = "WELLESLEY COLLEGE
> ASTRONOMY DEPARTMENT
> WELLESLEY, MA 02181"
>
> Please verify which is correct.
Done.
> H. line 94, see comment (9.E.) above.
>
> I. line 95, this file - REGISTRATION_DATE = "UNK"
> data dictionary has - REGISTRATION_DATE = "1994-08-15"
>
> Insert dd value for "UNK".
Done.
> 10. \CATALOG\REF.CAT
>
> A. See (6.A.), (7.A.), and (8.A.) above.
Done.
> B. FRENCHETAL2003, capitalize words in reference title,
> (unless they are not capitalized as paper/document
> actually published).
>
> C. MURRAY&GIULIATTI1996, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> D. BOSH&RIVKIN1996, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> E. DOURNEAU&BARATCH1999, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> F. DURIEZ&VIENNE1997, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> G. GIULIATTIWINETAL2000, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> H. HARPER&TAYLOR1993, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> I. HARPER&TAYLOR1994, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> J. NICHOLSONETAL1992, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> K. NICHOLSONETAL1996, please double check title of this
> paper. Data dictionary has
> "...crossings in August and November 1995".
> Your reference does not have "1995".
>
> L. POULET&SICARDY2001, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> M. VIENNE&DURIEZ1995, see (10.B.) comments above.
>
> N. SYNNOTTETAL1983, see (10.B.) comments above.
Done.
> 11. \INDEX\INDEX.LBL
>
> A. line 19
>
> change
> ROW_BYTES = 205
> to
> ROW_BYTES = 204
>
> Table will not display correctly when using "205" value.
> Once change made, table looks fine. (ROW_BYTES is the byte
> length of each record plus two bytes for the <cr><lf>
> characters).
Done.
> 12. \DATA\EASYDATA\*.LBL
>
> A. SOURCE_FILE_NAME = *
>
> 1. Capitalize file names, (as they are capitalized on
> the volume.)
>
> 2. Include full pathname, (since they do not reside in
> the same directory). For example:
>
> change:
>
> SOURCE_FILE_NAME = "Dione_table_rev2.txt"
>
> to:
>
> SOURCE_FILE_NAME = "\DATA\SORCDATA\DIONE_TABLE_REV2.TXT"
Done.
> B. I didn't look at every table, just picked three at random,
> of the eleven total. They look fine.
>
> C. PRODUCT_TYPE = ASTROMETRY_TABLE
>
> The PRODUCT_TYPE keyword was originally defined for image
> data, (i.e. GENERAL_CLASSIFICATION_TYPE = "IMAGING"). But,
> the keyword seems appropriate here. Let me get an okay
> from Ron. Will advise.
ASTROMETRY_TABLE is now a
recognized standard value. Thanks.
> D. See (6.C.) comments above, (specifically the INSTRUMENT_NAME
> keyword).
Done.
> 13. \DATA\SORCDATA\*.LBL
>
> A. SORCE_FILE_NAME = *
>
> See comments for (12.A.1.) above.
Done.
> B. \DATA\SORCDATA\DIONE_TABLE_REV2.LBL
>
> line 39, move opening paranthesis to next line
Done.
> C. The above comment (13.B.) applies to all the files in this
> sub-directory, (but the line number changes slightly with
> each file).
Done.
> D. See (12.C.) comments above.
Done.
> E. See (6.C.) comments above, (specifically the INSTRUMENT_NAME
> keyword).
Done.
> 14. ISO/ASCII character check: okay
>
> 15. Test ingestion: (no changes requested, just noted here for
> documentation purposes), the following changes needed for
> successful test ingestion.
>
> A. Add VOLONLINE object to VOLDESC.CAT
>
> B. DATASET.CAT
>
> 1. DATA_SET_NAME keyword - place opening quote
> of keyword value on same line as keyword.
>
> 2. Add LABEL_REVISION_NOTE keyword/value.
>
> 16. Relational Integrity check: (no changes requested, just noted here
> for documentation purposes).
>
> A. Five relational integrity errors introduced by this volume.
>
> 1. dsinfo14 - dsinfo.dsid / dsnssdc.dscolldsid
> MISSING KEY VALUE: {HST-S-WFPC2-4-ASTROM2002-V1.0}
>
> 2. dsinfo16 - dsinfo.dsid / invnodemedia.dscolldsid
> MISSING KEY VALUE: {HST-S-WFPC2-4-ASTROM2002-V1.0}
>
> 3. msnhost3 - targetinfo.targname
> MISSING KEY VALUE: {CHARON}
>
> 4. volds02 - volds.dscolldsid / invnodemedia.dscolldsid
> MISSING KEY VALUE: {HST-S-WFPC2-4-ASTROM2002-V1.0}
>
> 5. volds03 - volds.dscolldsid / dsnssdc.dscolldsid
> MISSING KEY VALUE: {HST-S-WFPC2-4-ASTROM2002-V1.0}
>
> (Errors 1, 2, 4, and 5 resolved by writing and ingesting a
> DSNSSDC.CAT and a INVNODEMEDIA.CAT. We will need to obtain
> from the NSSDC a NSSDC_DATA_SET_ID for these files first
> before being able to ingest into the catalog. Samples of
> these two files can be found at:
> pdsproto-web/OnlineTemplate/Adams/NEAR2/
>
> Error 3 will be resolved by ingesting a new TARGET.CAT for
> Charon.)
>
> <eof>