From: "rjoyner" To: "Mark Showalter" Subject: Comments on RPX_0001 Date: Thu, 26 Aug 1999 07:25:11 -0700 Comments to: Mark Showalter RINGS-RPX-0001 5 Aug 99 Peer review comments These are my initial comments on RPX_0001. If you have any questions, and I expect that you will, please call and we can work thru any issues. (1) ...\CALMASK\*.LBL (a) The COMPRESSED_FILE object is required to have a FILE_RECORDS keyword. I believe we talked about this in one of our meetings ??? (2) CATALOG/SOFTWARE.LBL (a) The template is missing END_OBJECT = SOFTWARE_INFORMATION See enclosure (3) CATALOG/REF.CAT (a) The following REFKEYID is present in the INSTHOST.CAT but not in the REF.CAT. Please add to REF.CAT: VOELS1995 (b) See the enclosure for the updated file. I have made minor corrections once again. It is not a good idea to enclose ref titles in single or double quotes because some titles include single quotes within the description. The best way is to not quote these expressions: OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "MACROBERT1995A" REFERENCE_DESC = "MacRobert, A.M., Ed., Saturn's rings turn edge on, Sky and Telescope 89, 68-71, May 1995." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE (4) INDEX/INDEX.LBL CUMINDEX.LBL (a) You must either rename the FILE_NAME column to FILE_SPECIFICATION_NAME. OR you must separate the directory information from the file name and add a column for PATH_NAME. (5) INDEX/OBSCMIDX.LBL OBSINDEX.LBL (a) Both of these files contain illegal characters which in this case are TABs. (6) CALIB/F130LP.TAB (a) This file is only terminated with . Once the file is terminated with , and ROW_BYTES = 23 is set, then the file displays correctly. But, there is a problem with NASAVIEW displaying this file for some reason. It displays correctly using TBTOOL. (7) Keyword / Value search The following invalid keyword-values were found. (1) DATA_SET_ID HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0 ---------------------------------------- Find 'HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0' in 'F:\INDEX\OBSCMIDX.LBL' : F:\INDEX\OBSCMIDX.LBL(7): DATA_SET_ID = "HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0" Found 'HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0' 1 time(s). ---------------------------------------- Find 'HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0' in 'F:\INDEX\OBSINDEX.LBL' : F:\INDEX\OBSINDEX.LBL(7): DATA_SET_ID = "HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0" Found 'HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0' 1 time(s). Search complete, found 'HST-S-WFPC2-4-V1.0' 2 time(s). (8) CATALOG/DATASET.CAT (a) Under CONFIDENCE_LEVEL_NOTE you include [BIRETTAETAL1993] as a reference. It might be more useful to summarize the paper, or include the paper in the documents directory. (9) DATA directories (a) You might consider including a DATA directory at the root and making the data directories subdirectories of this one. It definitely makes the CD cleaner and it is very obvious where to find the data. (10) DATA/CALIMAGE/*.LBL /CALMASK/*.LBL /ENGDATA/*.LBL /ENGMASK/*.LBL /HEADER/*.LBL /RAWIMAGE/*.LBL /RAWMASK/*.LBL (a) Within these label files, byte offsets are lowercase. The standards are unclear on this point. But, CN has decided that the units should be either uppercase or lowercase. However, NasaView currently crashes when encountering lowercase units. So, please convert the --->>> . We will fix NasaView later. (11) DATA/BROWSE/*.GIF - able to view in Internet Explorer /CALIMAGE/*.IMG - able to view in NasaView /CALMASK/*.ZIP - able to explode and view /ENGDATA/*.ZIP - able to explode and view /ENGMASK/*.ZIP - able to explode and view /HEADER/*.ZIP - able to explode and view /RAWIMAGE/*.ZIP - able to explode and view /RAWMASK/*.ZIP - able to explode and view (a) Unzip - when I unzip the files in the RAWMASK directory the PKUNZIP program displayes the file names in lowercase. The NT operating system displays the unzipped files in uppercase. I have not tested this on UNIX, but I am concerned that the files may be created with lowercase names ??? (b) All of the label files require extensive editing in order to get NasaView to process the label/data. None of these problems are due to label errors. The new compressed objects are of course a problem that needs to be fixed within NasaView. Other problems include: - if the NOTE keyword-value exceeds 60 characters, NasaView will crash. - some of the other extraneous keywords (either placement of or inclusion of) crashes NasaView. I think we should include a note in the ERRATA.TXT file that the current version of NasaView (2.5.2) cannot display the data. ==================== SOFTWARE.CAT ==================== PDS_VERSION_ID = PDS3 LABEL_REVISION_NOTE = "M.R. SHOWALTER, 1998-10-01" RECORD_TYPE = STREAM OBJECT = SOFTWARE SOFTWARE_ID = UNZIP SOFTWARE_VERSION_ID = "5.32" OBJECT = SOFTWARE_INFORMATION SOFTWARE_NAME = "Unzip 5.32" DATA_FORMAT = ZIP SOFTWARE_LICENSE_TYPE = PUBLIC_DOMAIN TECHNICAL_SUPPORT_TYPE = NONE REQUIRED_STORAGE_BYTES = 3.1MB PDS_USER_ID = MSHOWALTER NODE_ID = RINGS SOFTWARE_DESC = " Software Overview ================= From the Info-ZIP web site, http://www.cdrom.com/pub/infozip/UnZip.html in September 1998: UnZip is an extraction utility for archives compressed in .zip format (also called 'zipfiles'). Although highly compatible both with PKWARE's PKZIP and PKUNZIP utilities for MS-DOS and with Info-ZIP's own Zip program, our primary objectives have been portability and non-MSDOS functionality. UnZip will list, test, or extract files from a .zip archive, commonly found on MS-DOS systems. The default behavior (with no options) is to extract into the current directory (and subdirectories below it) all files from the specified zipfile. A companion program, Zip, creates .zip archives; both programs are compatible with archives created by PKZIP and PKUNZIP for MS-DOS, but in many cases the program options or default behaviors differ. (For example, UnZip recreates the stored directory structure by default; PKUNZIP unpacks all files in the current directory by default.) Available Support Material ========================== BINARIES, SOURCE_CODE Programming Language ==================== ANSII_C, OTHER Platforms Supported =================== Amiga AOS/VS Atari BeOS FlexOS Human68K (X68000) Macintosh MS-DOS/PC-DOS/DR-DOS MVS / OS/390 OpenEdition Novell Netware OS/2 QDOS/SMSQ Tandem NSK Unix: AIX, CLIX, Convex, Digital Unix (OSF/1)/Ultrix, FreeBSD, HP/UX, Linux, QNX, SCO Unix, SGI Irix, Solaris/SunOS VM/CMS VMS Windows 3.x Windows 95/Windows NT Windows CE Support Software Required/Used ============================== NONE " END_OBJECT = SOFTWARE_INFORMATION OBJECT = SOFTWARE_ONLINE ON_LINE_IDENTIFICATION = "http://www.cdrom.com/pub/infozip/" ON_LINE_NAME = "Unzip 5.32" NODE_ID = "N/A" PROTOCOL_TYPE = URL PLATFORM = "ANY" END_OBJECT = SOFTWARE_ONLINE OBJECT = SOFTWARE_PURPOSE SOFTWARE_PURPOSE = DECOMPRESSION END_OBJECT = SOFTWARE_PURPOSE END_OBJECT = SOFTWARE END =========== REF.CAT =========== PDS_VERSION_ID = PDS3 LABEL_REVISION_NOTE = "M.R. SHOWALTER, 1998-10-01" RECORD_TYPE = STREAM /* References describing results from Saturn RPX observations using */ /* WFPC2 */ OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BIRETTAETAL1993" REFERENCE_DESC = "Biretta, J.A., S.M. Baggett, J.W. MacKenty, C.E. Ritchie, and W.B. Sparks, The WFPC Calibration Pipeline, Proceedings of the HST Calibration Workshop (Baltimore: STScI), 8-19, November, 1993." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BIRETTAETAL1996" REFERENCE_DESC = "Biretta, J.A., C. Burrows, J. Holtzman, I. Heyer, M. Stevens, S. Baggaett, S. Casertano, M. Clampin, A. Fruchter, H. Ferguson, R. Gilliland, R. Griffiths, J. Krist, K. Noll, C. O'Dea, M. Stiavelli, A.Suchkov, J. Surdej, and B. Whitmore, The WFPC Instrument Handbook, Version 4.0 (Baltimore: STScI), June, 1996." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BOSH&RIVKIN1996" REFERENCE_DESC = "Bosh, A.S., and A.S. Rivkin, Observations of Saturn's inner satellites during the May 1995 ring-plane crossing, Science 272, 518-521, 1996." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BURROWS1994" REFERENCE_DESC = "Burrows, C.J., ed., Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 Instrument Handbook, Version 2.0, (Baltimore: STScI), May, 1994." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "BURROWSETAL1991" REFERENCE_DESC = "Burrows, C.J., J.A. Holtzman, S.M. Faber, P.Y. Bely, H. Hasan, C.R. Lynds, and D. Schroeder, The Imaging Performance of the Hubble Space Telescope, Ap. J. Lett. 369, L21-L25, 1991." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "HOLTZMANETAL1995A" REFERENCE_DESC = "Holtzman, J., J.J. Hester, S. Casertano, J.T. Trauger, A.M. Watson, G.E. Ballester, C.J. Burrows, J.T. Clarke, D. Crisp, R.W. Evans, J.S. Gallagher III, R.E. Griffiths, J.G. Hoessel, L.D. Matthews, J.R. Mould, P.A. Scowen, K.R. Stapelfeldt, and J.A. Westphal, The Performance and Calibration of WFPC2 on the Hubble Space Telescope, Publ. Astron. Soc. Pacific 107, 156-178, 1995." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "HOLTZMANETAL1995B" REFERENCE_DESC = "Holtzman, J.A., C.J. Burrows, S. Casertano, J.J. Hester, J.T. Trauger, A.M. Watson, and G. Worthey, The Photometric Performance and Calibration of WFPC2, Publ. Astron. Soc. Pacific 107, 1065-1093, 1995." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "KARKOSCHKA&LOREN1997" REFERENCE_DESC = "Karkoschka, E., and R.D. Lorenz, Latitudinal variation of aerosol sizes inferred from Titan's shadow, Icarus 125, 369-379, 1997." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "LORENZETAL1997" REFERENCE_DESC = "Lorenz, R.D., P.H. Smith, M.T. Lemmon, E. Karkoschka, G.W. Lockwood, and J. Caldwell, Titan's north-south asymmetry from HST and Voyager imaging: Comparison with models and ground-based photometry, Icarus 127, 173-189, 1997." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "MACROBERT1995A" REFERENCE_DESC = "MacRobert, A.M., Ed., Saturn's rings turn edge on, Sky and Telescope 89, 68-71, May, 1995." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "MACROBERT1995B" REFERENCE_DESC = "MacRobert, A.M., Ed., Saturn again turns ringless, Sky and Telescope 90, 72-77, August, 1995." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE OBJECT = REFERENCE REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "NICHOLSONETAL1996" REFERENCE_DESC = "Nicholson, P.D., M.R. Showalter, L. Dones, R.G. French, S.M. Larson, J.J. Lissauer, C.A. McGhee, P. Seitzer, B. Sicardy, and G.E. Danielson, Observations of Saturn's ring plane crossings in August and November 1995, Science 272, 509-515, 1996." END_OBJECT = REFERENCE END