VGISS_5,7,8xxx Jupiter, Uranus, Neptune

Responses to Reviewers' Comments

The data set has gone through substantial revisions since the peer review. The major changes are as follows:

1. A review of the process revealed that our copy of input file “VGRSCF.DAT” contained the exact same scaling factors for Neptune as for Uranus, so that all I/Fs from the Neptune encounter were small by a factor of ~ 2.5. We have repaired the error in VGRSCF.DAT and have re-calibrated the entire Neptune data set. We have also run the quality tests and the end again to ensure everything is OK. Checks of the image in question confirm that I/Fs for Uranus and Neptune are now similar. The correction is documented in PROCESSING.TXT, and we have also archived the corrected version of VGRSCF.DAT in the CALIB subdirectory on the last Neptune volume.
2. It was found that many of the Uranus and Neptune images had inadvertently been calibrated using ADESPIKE instead of DESPIKE. he latter is newer and produces superior results. Also, some Uranus and Neptune images were not processed using VGRFILLIN, which resulted in horizontal stripes near the edges of some images. All Uranus and Neptune images were re- processed using VGRFILLIN and DESPIKE. Note that the Neptune images were also calibrated using the corrected version of VGRSCF.DAT, as discussed above. All quality tests were then repeated. Side-by-side comparisons of the new and old versions of selected images confirm that the new versions are distinctly cleaner and that the Neptune scale factors are correct.
3. The labels for the raw files did not include the (undocumented) ENGINEERING_TABLE object, which occupies the second and third record of each file. The labels have been corrected.
4. We transcribed the tables from Danielson et al. 1981 and added them to the DOCUMENT/REPORTS subdirectory. We also standardized the DOCUMENT directory across all volumes except for the encounter-specific files PROCESSING.TXT and TUTORIAL.TXT. This is explained in DOCINFO.TXT.
5. PRODUCT_CREATION_TIMES were updated to reflect the new processing.
6. Numerous documentation files were updated, including TUTORTIAL.TXT, PROCESSING.TXT, AAREADME.TXT, DATASET.CAT, INDEX.TAB, ERRATA.TXT, and most of the PDS .LBL files.

1. We have not yet augmented the geometric information about the images. This is the subject of ongoing work at the Rings Node, along with similar work for the Cassini mission. This work is incomplete at this time but will be included in a future update to the data sets.
2. We have not yet corrected targets currently identified as "UNK_SAT". These will be corrected along with the augmented geometry information.
3. We have not yet documented a few very old file formats that are archived primarily to support current users of VICAR. Charlie Avis has agreed to provide some of this information, and we will include it in an update.

The Data

The new archival versions of these volumes are on line here:

Jupiter

• VGISS_5101 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 13854.55 -- 14998.32
• VGISS_5102 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15000.55 -- 15199.31
• VGISS_5103 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15201.54 -- 15400.00
• VGISS_5104 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15400.02 -- 15449.58
• VGISS_5105 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15450.00 -- 15498.38
• VGISS_5106 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15508.28 -- 15598.27
• VGISS_5107 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15600.34 -- 15699.58
• VGISS_5108 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15700.00 -- 15799.26
• VGISS_5109 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15801.30 -- 15898.42
• VGISS_5110 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 15900.49 -- 15997.57
• VGISS_5111 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16000.03 -- 16099.34
• VGISS_5112 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16100.05 -- 16199.59
• VGISS_5113 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16200.00 -- 16249.25
• VGISS_5114 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16250.03 -- 16299.59
• VGISS_5115 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16300.01 -- 16349.55
• VGISS_5116 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16350.03 -- 16399.59
• VGISS_5117 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16400.00 -- 16448.00
• VGISS_5118 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16450.47 -- 16495.24
• VGISS_5119 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 16501.03 -- 16983.05
• VGISS_5120 (.tar.gz): Voyager 1, FDS 17182.42 -- 17574.27
• VGISS_5201 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 18110.30 -- 18798.52
• VGISS_5202 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 18801.17 -- 19198.24
• VGISS_5203 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 19200.49 -- 19399.59
• VGISS_5204 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 19400.02 -- 19594.52
• VGISS_5205 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 19602.10 -- 19798.25
• VGISS_5206 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 19800.23 -- 19999.26
• VGISS_5207 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20001.33 -- 20195.57
• VGISS_5208 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20209.44 -- 20301.26
• VGISS_5209 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20301.29 -- 20399.57
• VGISS_5210 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20400.00 -- 20498.07
• VGISS_5211 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20501.24 -- 20549.59
• VGISS_5212 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20550.03 -- 20593.54
• VGISS_5213 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20603.35 -- 20649.58
• VGISS_5214 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 20650.01 -- 20863.06

Uranus

• VGISS_7201 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 24476.54 -- 24987.59
• VGISS_7202 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 25027.59 -- 25992.59
• VGISS_7203 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 26002.27 -- 26288.57
• VGISS_7204 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 26302.41 -- 26594.14
• VGISS_7205 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 26602.52 -- 26799.52
• VGISS_7206 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 26800.06 -- 26999.54
• VGISS_7207 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 27000.00 -- 27628.47

Neptune

• VGISS_8201 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS   8966.31 --   9497.48
• VGISS_8202 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS   9505.56 --   9998.46
• VGISS_8203 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 10002.47 -- 10378.23
• VGISS_8204 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 10404.40 -- 10798.16
• VGISS_8205 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 10826.20 -- 10999.59
• VGISS_8206 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 11000.05 -- 11199.50
• VGISS_8207 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 11200.00 -- 11399.51
• VGISS_8208 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 11400.02 -- 11599.59
• VGISS_8209 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 11600.06 -- 11935.40
• VGISS_8210 (.tar.gz): Voyager 2, FDS 12009.27 -- 12457.33

The archival versions contain significant changes over the peer review versions, and should be used for research activities. For continuity, the peer review volumes remain on line here:

Jupiter

• VGISS_5101 Voyager 1, FDS 13854.55 -- 14998.32
• VGISS_5102 Voyager 1, FDS 15000.55 -- 15199.31
• VGISS_5103 Voyager 1, FDS 15201.54 -- 15400.00
• VGISS_5104 Voyager 1, FDS 15400.02 -- 15449.58
• VGISS_5105 Voyager 1, FDS 15450.00 -- 15498.38
• VGISS_5106 Voyager 1, FDS 15508.28 -- 15598.27
• VGISS_5107 Voyager 1, FDS 15600.34 -- 15699.58
• VGISS_5108 Voyager 1, FDS 15700.00 -- 15799.26
• VGISS_5109 Voyager 1, FDS 15801.30 -- 15898.42
• VGISS_5110 Voyager 1, FDS 15900.49 -- 15997.57
• VGISS_5111 Voyager 1, FDS 16000.03 -- 16099.34
• VGISS_5112 Voyager 1, FDS 16100.05 -- 16199.59
• VGISS_5113 Voyager 1, FDS 16200.00 -- 16249.25
• VGISS_5114 Voyager 1, FDS 16250.03 -- 16299.59
• VGISS_5115 Voyager 1, FDS 16300.01 -- 16349.55
• VGISS_5116 Voyager 1, FDS 16350.03 -- 16399.59
• VGISS_5117 Voyager 1, FDS 16400.00 -- 16448.00
• VGISS_5118 Voyager 1, FDS 16450.47 -- 16495.24
• VGISS_5119 Voyager 1, FDS 16501.03 -- 16983.05
• VGISS_5120 Voyager 1, FDS 17182.42 -- 17574.27
• VGISS_5201 Voyager 2, FDS 18110.30 -- 18798.52
• VGISS_5202 Voyager 2, FDS 18801.17 -- 19198.24
• VGISS_5203 Voyager 2, FDS 19200.49 -- 19399.59
• VGISS_5204 Voyager 2, FDS 19400.02 -- 19594.52
• VGISS_5205 Voyager 2, FDS 19602.10 -- 19798.25
• VGISS_5206 Voyager 2, FDS 19800.23 -- 19999.26
• VGISS_5207 Voyager 2, FDS 20001.33 -- 20195.57
• VGISS_5208 Voyager 2, FDS 20209.44 -- 20301.26
• VGISS_5209 Voyager 2, FDS 20301.29 -- 20399.57
• VGISS_5210 Voyager 2, FDS 20400.00 -- 20498.07
• VGISS_5211 Voyager 2, FDS 20501.24 -- 20549.59
• VGISS_5212 Voyager 2, FDS 20550.03 -- 20593.54
• VGISS_5213 Voyager 2, FDS 20603.35 -- 20649.58
• VGISS_5214 Voyager 2, FDS 20650.01 -- 20863.06

Uranus

• VGISS_7201 Voyager 2, FDS 24476.54 -- 24987.59
• VGISS_7202 Voyager 2, FDS 25027.59 -- 25992.59
• VGISS_7203 Voyager 2, FDS 26002.27 -- 26288.57
• VGISS_7204 Voyager 2, FDS 26302.41 -- 26594.14
• VGISS_7205 Voyager 2, FDS 26602.52 -- 26799.52
• VGISS_7206 Voyager 2, FDS 26800.06 -- 26999.54
• VGISS_7207 Voyager 2, FDS 27000.00 -- 27628.47

Neptune

• VGISS_8201 Voyager 2, FDS   8966.31 --   9497.48
• VGISS_8202 Voyager 2, FDS   9505.56 --   9998.46
• VGISS_8203 Voyager 2, FDS 10002.47 -- 10378.23
• VGISS_8204 Voyager 2, FDS 10404.40 -- 10798.16
• VGISS_8205 Voyager 2, FDS 10826.20 -- 10999.59
• VGISS_8206 Voyager 2, FDS 11000.05 -- 11199.50
• VGISS_8207 Voyager 2, FDS 11200.00 -- 11399.51
• VGISS_8208 Voyager 2, FDS 11400.02 -- 11599.59
• VGISS_8209 Voyager 2, FDS 11600.06 -- 11935.40
• VGISS_8210 Voyager 2, FDS 12009.27 -- 12457.33

Reviewers' Submitted Comments

• Charlie Avis
• Richard Chen
• Chen vtool report
• Amy Culver
• Kathy Rages
• comparison tiff image
• Bob West (PDF) (.docx)

Responses to Review Comments

Consolidated review comments annotated with Rings Node responses in green.

• Review summary (PDF) with responses in green.

Individual reviews with responses in green.

• Charlie Avis (PDF)
• Richard Chen (PDF)
• Amy Culver (PDF)
• Kathy Rages (PDF)
• comparison tiff image
• Bob West (PDF)