VG_2801 peer-review volume validation report

0. general comments

A. Pretty clean volume, just a couple of minor things, good

work. I look at pretty much everything, and didn't find

anything major.

B. test ingestion, successful, with the changes detailed

below, (i.e., 2.B.1., 2.B.2., 2.D.1., 2.D.2.)

C. test relational integrity check, successful, with

the inclusion of a dummy invonodemedia.cat and dummy

dsnssds.cat

D. spell check nor grammar check conducted on ASCII files on

this volume.

1. root

A. AAREADME.TXT

1. typos

a. line 22, invlude

b. line 36, (e.g. Macintosh,

should be (e.g., Macintosh,

2. line 70, URL of std. ref. doc. incorrect, should be

http://pds.jpl.nasa.gov/documents/

3. line 170, illegal ASCII character, <tab> character

Corrected all.

B. ERRATA.TXT

1. line 21, change ...words, e.g.

to ...words, e.g.,

Corrected.

C. VOLDESC.CAT

1. missing VG1HOST.CAT in CATALOG directory

Added.

^INSTRUMENT_HOST_CATALOG = {"VG1HOST.CAT", "VG2HOST.CAT"}

2. line 23, FACILITY_NAME = "SPACE SCIENCE DIVISION"

data dictionary has "SPACE SCIENCE LABORATORY"

Which should it be?

Neither. Replaced with the correct information.

2. CATALOG

A. CATINFO.TXT

1. nothing to report (ntr)

B. DATASET.CAT

1. CITATION_DESC missing closing quote.

Corrected.

2. missing required DATA_SET_MISSION object;

insert the following object, just after

END_OBJECT = DATA_SET_INFORMATION

OBJECT = DATA_SET_MISSION

MISSION_NAME = "VOYAGER"

END_OBJECT = DATA_SET_MISSION

Added.

C. MISSION.CAT

1. ntr

D. PERSON.CAT

1. line 16, change

PDS_AFFILIATION = "RINGS NODE MANAGER"

to

PDS_AFFILIATION = "NODE MANAGER"

2. line 44, change

PDS_AFFILIATION = "RINGS NODE ASSISTANT MANAGER"

to

PDS_AFFILIATION = "NODE STAFF"

Corrected.

E. REF.CAT

1. lines 109-114, FRENCHETAL1993, your listing in

REF.CAT is incomplete (i.e., et al.). The ingested

version contains the full author list. Replace

the version in this file with the same as alread

ingested.

Corrected.

This reference exists in the REF.CAT file, but is

not contained in any other catalog file. Perhaps

just delete it form the REF.CAT?

Retained since it is important to potential users.

F. VG1HOST.CAT

1. this file is listed in the VOLDESC.CAT file,

but is not included in this sub-directory

Added.

G. VG1NINST.CAT

1. line 841, REFERENCE_KEY_ID = "SNYDER,L1979"

invalid value, does not exist in REF.CAT, not

in body of document, delete object.

Corrected REFERENCE_KEY_ID & added to the REF.CAT file.

2. line 825, line 829, line 833, and line 837,

as above, (2.G.1.), delete objects.

Added to REF.CAT

H. VG2HOST.CAT

1. ntr

I. VG2NINST.CAT

1. line 1014, as above, (2.G.1.) delete object.

Corrected REFERENCE_KEY_ID & added to the REF.CAT file.

2. line 998, line 1002, line 1006, and line 1010,

as above, (2.G.1.), delete objects.

Added to REF.CAT

3. DATA

A. IS1_P0001_IMAGES

1. /DATA/IS1_P0001_IMAGES/CLEANED

PRODUCT_TYPE = CLEANED_IMAGE

CLEANED_IMAGE is a new std value.

B. IS2_POOO1_IMAGES

1. /DATA/IS2_P0001_IMAGES/CLEANED

as above (3.A.1.)

C. DATAINFO.TXT

1. ntr

D. directory level data files and label files

1. ntr

4. DOCUMENT

A. DOCINFO.TXT

1. ntr

B. PROFILES.TXT

1. ntr

C. SOURCE_FORMAT.TXT

1. illegal ASCII character, OChex, ASCII 12, multiple

lines, (i.e., lines 13, 59, 113, 170, 226, 281,

341, 400, 459, 517, 576, 634, 689, 748, 789, 842,

901, 923, 975, 1018, 1076, 1136, 1188, 1246, 1305,

1359, 1417, 1475, 1531, 1588, and 1624)

Replaced.

5. INDEX

A. INDXINFO.TXT

1. ntr

B. INDEX.LBL

1. ntr

C. INDEX.TAB

1. ntr

<eof>